One Tower For All: When The Goal Outweighs Life

Rabbi Shay Tahan

This week’s Torah portion takes us to the first communist regime in history, revealing how such systems gradually, and with great cunning, take shape. The story unfolds some time after the Flood, as the world begins to rebuild itself. As in any society, social classes soon emerged—rich and poor, strong and weak, successful and struggling. Humanity had learned a lesson from the Generation of the Flood: not to be selfish and corrupt, not to steal from one another or act violently. Yet now, a new religion arose—a seemingly noble and positive faith: the religion of social equality.
This new “faith” was founded by a man who rose to greatness—Nimrod, who began to rule over Babylon: “And the beginning of his kingdom was Babel.” Like every charismatic leader, Nimrod was not content with partial rule; he sought global dominion. As our Sages taught (Chullin 89a): “I gave greatness to Nimrod, and he said: ‘Come, let us build a city.’”
But how would Nimrod draw people to follow him? What could he offer? He understood early on that the best way to win the masses was to promise them wealth, comfort, and security. How could this be achieved? Free public transportation, low rent with no increases, government-run markets where everyone is equal, free healthcare, and so on.
But where would the funding come from? The answer is simple—take from the rich and establish a socialist-communist government. The Sages (זבחים קיג, ב) comment on the city Shinar, saying its name implies “it shakes out its wealthy.” Yet this was not done all at once—it was a slow process: high taxation and economic pressure until the wealthy were gradually stripped of their assets.
Still, Nimrod knew this alone would not suffice. Others had promised equality before him. He needed something greater, deeper, more inspiring. He needed to found a religion. A religion does not necessarily require a god—it can be built around an idea, a lofty ideal that captures the hearts of the masses. But every religion needs certain elements: a goal with a plan, an enemy to fight, a place of worship, and sacrifices.
The goal was clear—to create absolute social equality. The plan was to unite everyone under one grand project that would consume their efforts, hearts, and minds. The chosen project was the Tower, symbolizing the ideology Nimrod preached. The Tower would serve not just as a monument but as the center of worship for this new faith.
Like every movement or religion, there had to be a common enemy—someone or something that all could unite against. Without an enemy, there is no unifying force. Thus they found their “villain” in God Himself. As the pasuk says, “He was a mighty hunter before Hashem,” which Rashi explains to mean: he ensnared people with words, turning them to rebel against Hashem. Now that there is a common enemy, everyone can direct their anger and frustration toward them; leaders can channel the crowd’s resentment outward. Since every person experiences failures and hardships in life, human nature seeks to avoid self-blame. Instead, people look for external causes to justify their shortcomings. Once a convenient villain is found, personal failures and disappointments are redirected away from oneself and projected onto that shared scapegoat.
In essence, Nimrod created a new religion and social order built on uniting the people around the dream of equality, while designating Hashem as the great oppressor to be overthrown. In his eyes, Hashem was to blame for the Flood in Noah’s time, for His “arrogance” over the dwellers of the earth (Rashi 11:1). Thus, Nimrod provided the perfect framework: confiscate the wealth of the rich, redistribute it “fairly,” and rally the people together against their supposed common enemy—the creator Himself. Nimrod’s system was both economic and psychological: control over property combined with control over emotion and belief.
Immediately, he set his plan into motion: “And the whole earth was of one language and of one speech.” Rashi explains that this was a unified movement to rise up against Hashem. Everyone had to contribute equally, giving up all they owned for the “greater good.”
Nimrod stirred the multitudes with visions of a new era, preaching that all the world’s suffering came from the primitive faith in one God, a dark and oppressive religion that had brought only floods, destruction, and death.

The religion of equality repeats itself throughout history. It reemerges in new guises, yet always follows the same pattern: it sweeps the masses with promises of justice and hope—and ends in devastation. It leaves behind economic collapse, moral decay, and spiritual ruin. Even today, we witness the return of this cunning movement, cloaked in the modern garments of “compassion” and “equality,” but beneath lies the same ancient root—the desire to erase personal responsibility, to dethrone the Creator, and to enthrone man and the state in His place.
in english